• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

GreyMatters

Electrical Earthing System Design & Soil Resistivity Testing

  • Home
  • About
    • Contact Us
  • Blog
  • Earthing Services
    • Earthing Design Services
    • Lightning Protection Design
  • Earthing Training Courses
  • XGSLab
    • XGSLab Services
    • XGSLab Online Demo
    • XGSLab Sales
  • Members Academy
Home » Ask the Experts Electrical Earthing Blog » Your Standard Earthing Design – Are They Valid Anymore?

03/09/2017 By Hugh Leave a Comment

Your Standard Earthing Design – Are They Valid Anymore?

A number of organisations across the UK recommend a standard earthing design when building smaller scale substations. The key driver behind these is one of cost. Nobody wants to pay more than they have to. For an HV connection using a templated approach to meet Earthing Standards compliance kind of makes sense – or does it?

So, the question is – does installing a standard earthing design meet your obligations under the Electricity at Work regulations?

Standard Earthing Design

Regulation 8 requires that:

Precautions shall be taken, either by earthing or by other suitable means, to prevent danger arising when any conductor (other than a circuit conductor) which may reasonably foreseeably become charged as a result of either the use of a system, or a fault in a system, becomes so charged; and, for the purposes of ensuring compliance with this regulation, a conductor shall be regarded as earthed when it is connected to the general mass of earth by conductors of sufficient strength and current-carrying capability to discharge electrical energy to earth.

ensuring compliance by force-fitting a standard design – is plain dangerous

In my opinion, the key part of this extract is the last phrase: i.e. “connected to the general mass of the earth by conductors of sufficient strength and current-carrying capability to discharge electrical energy to earth.”  WHY?

Standard Earthing Design – in a non-standard world.

You’ve checked that the conductors are of the correct ampacity – surely that’s enough, right? WRONG! Let’s look at the last 5 words – discharge electrical energy to earth.

If you’ve already checked that the conductors can transport the energy away from the location of the fault, that’s great. But if it has nowhere to go, then it’s almost pointless.

Its All About the Soil Resistivity

As mentioned previously, the key underpinning to any electrical earth system is a soil resistivity study. I.e. determining the capability of the soil to absorb the electrical energy dissipated by the earth (soil conduction). As a result, how does the earth system design comply with standards, for a substation next to a river? If actually, you instal the substation at the top of a mountain. And, observing the different geology likely.

BS EN 50522

BS EN 50522 referenced since 2010, for HV earth systems compliance. Though most DNOs refer to the older ENA TS 41-24. Both of these standards define compliance in terms of step and touch voltages, i.e. safety from the system. A compliant earthing system is one where step and touch voltages are kept below the thresholds determined by the above standards, instead of the redundant standard earthing design – “less than the 1-Ohm rule”.

Ask Yourself Questions

Once you know the soil resistivity for the site, you can start thinking about the electrical earthing system design. Questions to ask are:

  • How much energy is there likely to be when a fault occurs? What is the fault level?
  • What other routes can the energy take? Is there a cable sheath? Is there a CPC with the cable?
  • How big is the substation?
  • What other land is available to deploy an earth electrode into?

If any single one of these points is based on an assumption. The design is either way over the top, so you’re installing much more copper than you need to. Or worse, the design is insufficient, and you could be sending your electrical maintenance staff into a danger area when they go to work in your substation.

We’re all passionate about delivering right-sized designs at GreyMatters. Earthing Design that ticks the safety compliance boxes, and also keeps the accountants and project leaders happy.

If someone working in your substation were to get injured and the substation had an insufficient earth system, your only defence is that you took all reasonable steps and exercised all reasonable due diligence. Sure, an Earthing Study is a few thousand pounds, but if someone were to die because the earthing system you installed wasn’t up to scratch, the damages alone would be significantly more.

Boy in a big suit
shoe-horning an ‘off the peg’ safe design into a standard specification

Historical Standard Earthing Design Specification

So historically, shoe-horning an ‘off the peg’ safe design into a standard specification to reach a set resistance value across the UK may have worked before 2010, but now, the bar has been significantly raised.

Feeling uncertain? Got any difficult questions whirring around? If so, we have an offer to help set your mind at rest.

For new UK-based customers, for a flat fee of 5k, we will visit one of your small (typically a GRP substation in a box) HV substations, do a soil resistivity test, measure the earth resistance, and put together an Earthing Study using the latest most powerful CDEGS software, that either sets your mind at ease, that the earth system is compliant with standards. Or, tells you the next steps to bring the substation into compliance (terms & conditions apply – for more information, please get in touch).

If you’ve got a problem you’d like us to look at, why not drop us a line on LiveChat

Engage with us…

  • Earthing Design Services & Lightning Protection Design – If high voltage power systems and lightning are causing you concern why not see how we can help with a quick ‘live chat’ below as a start.
  • XGSLab – A complete software tool for the simulation of  Power, Earthing, Grounding and Lightning Systems, get in touch to request a free demo.
  • Get Certified – Start your journey to become certified in Power Systems Earthing & Design.
  • E-Learning – Introduction to Earthing, get a free trial here.
  • Get answers quickly using the searchable Technical Blog section.

Filed Under: Earthing System Design Tagged With: BS EN 50522, BS EN 50522-2010, earthing design, earthing standards, Electrical Earthing System Design, HV Earthing, HV Earthing Protection

Electrical Earthing Training – Free Trial

Do you want to understand more about Electrical Earthing System Design – Greymatters Academy is our Earthing Training site take a look or access your free trial here.

Recent Posts:

Ian getting ready

We take a look at soil resistivity and provide practical advice on what is ground soil resistivity, why we measure it and these common mistakes when Soil Resistivity Testing:

Soil Resistivity Testing Methods Wenner 4 Probe Test

Soil Resistivity Testing Methods a popular post. Originally published in 2013 and now updated. A Wenner probe test is a geotechnical investigation method used to determine the electrical resistivity of the soil. Soil resistivity testing can be carried out using different methods. The Wenner 4 Probe test is one of the most common soil resistivity […]

Schlumberger Array

The Schlumberger array is a geotechnical investigation method which determines the electrical resistivity of the soil. This is similar to the Wenner probe test, but it uses multiple current electrodes rather than just two. This allows for a more detailed and accurate measurement of soil resistivity. Soil resistivity testing carried out using different methods, this […]

Driven Rod Method

The driven rod test is a geotechnical investigation method which determines the resistance of soil to the penetration of a rod or other penetrometer.  The Soil resistivity is determined using different Soil Resistivity Testing methods. However the Driven Rod, described below is the last of the three most popular Soil Resistivity Testing methods we use […]

2022 webinar - the highlights

Knowing in today’s world it’s all about time. We’ve summarise hours of technical content into this 20-minute bite-sized session, including the key highlights from the 2022 webinar series. If you missed it, watch the webinar replay here. In this webinar we cover:

About Hugh

Reader Interactions

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

GreyMatters Accreditations

GreyMatters Accreditations

Online Earthing Courses

Free Trial Learn More

Free Online Course – Learn Ohms Law in 10 minutes or less!

Learn Ohms Law

Blog Categories

  • Acadamy (2)
  • Anti-Theft (1)
  • CDEGS (6)
  • Earth Testing (6)
  • Earthing Designs (7)
  • Earthing System Design (16)
  • Earthing Systems (5)
  • Electrical Earthing (38)
  • Energy Modelling Software (1)
  • General Post (10)
  • Grounding (1)
  • Lightning (11)
  • Lightning Protection Design (16)
  • Lightning Strike (1)
  • Renewable Energy (2)
  • Soil Resistivity (18)
  • Soil Resistivity Testing (10)
  • Solar (4)
  • XGSLab Updates (3)

Tag Cloud

BS7430 BS EN 50522 CDEGS data centres earth electrode Earthing earthing design earthing protection earthing standards Earthing system design earthing systems earth potential rise earth systems Electrical Earthing System Design Electromagnetic Field Theory electromagnetic interference EMI EN 50522 EPR Finite Element Analysis Finite Element Analysis Software greymatters Grounding HV Earthing HV Earthing Protection lightning lightning danger Lightning Protection lightning strikes Renewable Energy Rise of Earth Potential risk management ROEP Soil Resistivity Soil Resistivity Methods Soil Resistivity Testing Soil Resistivity Testing 10 Common Mistakes Soil Resistivity Testing Methods soil structure Step Potential Surge Protection Tag Archive - Lightning Strike Touch Potential what to do in a thunderstorm what to do when lightning strikes

Footer

  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Cookies
GREYMATTERS PART OF THE GROUP OF COMPANIES © 2023