• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

GreyMatters

Electrical Earthing System Design & Soil Resistivity Testing

  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Earthing Services
    • Earthing Design Services
    • Earth Monitoring System
    • Lightning Protection Design
    • Earthing Training Courses
  • Earthing Solutions
  • XGSLab
    • XGSLab Services
    • XGSLab Online Demo
    • XGSLab Sales
  • Contact Us
You are here: Home / Electrical Earthing / CDEGS / 50 Shades Darker – CDEGS Myths Busted!

26/03/2015 By Ian Leave a Comment

50 Shades Darker – CDEGS Myths Busted!

CDEGS Modelling Software demystified!

It’s interesting how the psychology of the car has found a place in our daily lives.  How many times have you asked or been asked ‘what car do you drive?’

If you’re one of the lucky few that own a Ferrari (unfortunately, I am not one of those!) – you might receive a different response than if you own a Nissan Micra.  The common thread is that there are both ‘cars’ aimed to transport you from A to B – but each one has been designed, developed and delivered to fit two very different budgets and to two very different purposes.

When to ask for black or white – not all CDEGS Modelling Software are the same!

 

CDEGS Modelling Software Demystified

In the land of cars, we measure performance in terms of acceleration (0-60 MPH), top speed, economy (MPG), ecology (g/CO2) or lap times if you’re a Top Gear fan …

In Earthing – the key performance measures (for EN 50522, 50122-1) are a function of accuracy % error, complexity, and/or correlation to reality.  The trouble is, one of the best-kept secrets is that different versions of “CDEGS Modelling Software” also exist – From the £7,000 Nissan Micra to the £200,000 Ferrari 488.

So, next time you receive a fee proposal for an Earthing Study that claims to be CDEGS compliant – ask the provider ‘what version/module of the CDEGS Modelling Software are you intending to use?’ Why (you might ask)?

The chief reason boils down to the engine that powers the modules – some modules, like MALT and MALZ rely on ‘Circuit Theory’.  Others, such as HI-FREQ are based in ‘Electromagnetic Field Theory’.

Why does this matter?

Two words … ERROR RATE.   If your application is on the simpler, smaller end of the earth design spectrum, with lower fault energisation levels; then the more budget sensitive versions of the CDEGS  Modelling Software which are based in Circuit Theory may be sufficient… but as the complexity and/or the size increases, so will the rate of error increases – sometimes as much as 50%.

Think about it – let’s say there’s a 6 kA fault with a 50% split factor.  This means there’s 3 kA going through the Main Earth System to earth.  For ease of calculation, let’s assume the Earth is 1 Ω impedance, which means the basic Earth Potential Rise (EPR) for the system should be around the 3 kV mark.

But what if the software module selected has underestimated the EPR by 50%?  This would lead to a 1.5 kV difference in predicted verses actual – is this significant??

I accept in this scenario mentioned, it’s not possible to be definitive without understanding a bit more about the circumstances but taking this at face value, an underestimate of 1.5 kV could have a significant impact on the touch/step safety – without putting too fine a point on it, enough to kill.

So, an upgrade in the computational engine is required for the larger, longer, more commonly encountered earth designs or studies for ‘power systems’, which can take account of mutual coupling effects, inductance, capacitance, e.g. the calculations are not limited to just the conductive/resistive effects.

Armed with an Electromagnetic Field Theory engine, the risk of error is mitigated – typically by an order of magnitude lower, which means we can all sleep at night because the design is using robust, accurate, low levels of error, based in the latest accepted science for its calculations.

If you have a ‘critical’ asset or infrastructure project – then the standard requirement has to be the elimination (or reduction at least) of error that can be easily avoided.  In most cases, this can be achieved by simply being more aware of the choices available and the residual risk in the modules used.  Knowingly or otherwise, no-one wants to be haunted by easily avoidable errors.

There’s a bewildering quantity of CDEGS modelling software modules – so if you’re not sure whether what is being used on your project is fit for purpose – drop us a line on our live chat facility below … for a super quick response.

Featured Image:  LaFerrari


  • About
  • Latest Posts

Ian Griffiths SelfieIan Griffiths

Ian is a Principal Consultant at GreyMatters, with 26 years experience solving HV earthing, EMC, and lightning problems for clients worldwide.  When he’s not busy studying problems and designing solutions, you can find him mountain biking, sailing and racing motorbikes in the summer.  In the winter he tends to head off to the mountains chasing the snow with friends and family.  Ian holds a Master’s Degree, and Degrees in both Mechanical and Electrical disciplines, and is one of the top 1% accredited CDEGS consultants and advisor to international utility companies, data-centre and infrastructure developers globally.

Recent Posts by Ian

50 Shades of GreyMatters

Real people, real answers in real time – the power of LIVE CHAT for our clients

GreyMatters – Protecting 100,000 lives through Earthing Design

Revolutionary CDEGS Software Shifting the Energy Industry

Filed Under: CDEGS Tagged With: 50122-1, BS7430, CDEGS, earth electrode, earth systems, Earthing, earthing design, Electromagnetic Field Theory, electromagnetic interference, EMF, EMI, EN 50522, greymatters, HI-FREQ, MALT, MALZ, safety earth, soil structure

Electrical Earthing Training – Free Trial

Do you want to understand more about Electrical Earthing System Design – Greymatters Academy is our Earthing Training site take a look or access your free trial here.

Recent Posts:

Are you feeling overwhelmed or out of your depth, well stop. Test drive our new online Training for Earthing courses. And say goodbye to PowerPoint slides forever! I don’t care how many tips and fixes there are out there on the info-web that claim to make boring training for earthing PowerPoint (PPT) slides less boring… […]

Comparing CDEGS with XGSLab

In his previous blog, Ian explained our decision to work with XGSLab, on the basis that it is an equally capable tool as CDEGS, that is much easier to use. In this blog, I’m going under to hood, so to speak. Comparing CDEGS with XGSLab to show you some real-world examples where CDEGS and XGSLab […]

XGSLab Electromagnetic Simulation Software

Since 2016, Greymatters prime purpose is to protect life. More personally, my goal is explicitly to save at least one life before I head off to the pearly gates and return into space dust. Knowing we’re focused on saving lives through the work we do. It makes sense that everything we do supports this goal, […]

Soil Resistivity Testing

Ground testing is typically performed in two stages. The first is conducted during the construction of a building to ensure proper installation of the electrical system. And the second involves routine ground testing to ensure the ‘actual’ arrangements perform as ‘predicted’ at the design stage. Thus, to avoid costly and fatal errors. What is the […]

Electrical earth testing can be a real challenge in built-up areas. Not only are there very few soft areas to deploy the test probes, but underground cabling and conductive structures are everywhere. These two factors massively affect the measured readings leading to measured values that bear no relation to the actual electrode tested.  Therefore, what […]

Earthing System Design A Probabilistic Approach

What are the procedures for creating an HV Earthing System Design? Also, how might these differ from an LV Earth design? Firstly, although the principles underpinning HV and LV earthing are similar, the approaches are very different. Probabilistic Approach The first huge difference is the recognition that HV electrical earthing design is probabilistic in nature. […]

About Ian

This post is written by Ian Griffiths, Principal Engineer at GreyMatters, an Earthing & Lightning Consultant of 27 years, one of the top 1% accredited CDEGS consultants and professional advisor to international utility companies, data centre and infrastructure developers.

Reader Interactions

You must log in to post a comment.

Primary Sidebar

Online Earthing Courses

Dominate Your Sector with
The GreyMatters Academy

Free Trial Learn More

Our Top Earthing Post

Electrical Fault Theory

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Blog Categories

  • Acadamy (2)
  • Anti-Theft (2)
  • Carbon Footprint (2)
  • CDEGS (5)
  • Earth Testing (5)
  • Earthing System Design (15)
  • Earthing Systems (7)
  • Eco (8)
  • Electrical Earthing (34)
  • General Post (44)
  • Lightning (10)
  • Lightning Protection Design (15)
  • Lightning Strike (3)
  • Newsletters (4)
  • Renewable Energy (7)
  • Soil Resistivity (16)
  • Soil Resistivity Testing (10)
  • Solar (8)
  • Wind (2)

Tag Cloud

BS7430 BS EN 50522 CDEGS copper theft data centres Earthing earthing design earthing standards Earthing system design earthing systems earth potential rise Eco Electrical Earthing System Design Electromagnetic Field Theory electromagnetic interference EMI EN 50522 Energy EPR Finite Element Analysis Finite Element Analysis Software gm people greymatters Grounding Helpful Tips In the Media lightning lightning danger Lightning Protection lightning strikes News newsletter Renewables Rise of Earth Potential ROEP Soil Resistivity Soil Resistivity Testing Soil Resistivity Testing 10 Common Mistakes Soil Resistivity Testing Methods soil structure solar south africa Tag Archive - Lightning Strike Videos what to do in a thunderstorm

Footer

Contact GreyMatters

Bristol and Bath Science Park
Dirac Crescent
Emersons Green
Bristol
BS16 7FR
+44 (0) 117 247 0050
hello@greymattersglobal.com
  • Terms
  • Privacy
  • Cookies

Copyright GreyMatters © 2019

This site uses cookies to improve your experience. Read more.